posted by admin on Mar 12
Just watched tonight’s “The Word” on The Colbert Report about conservative TV pundits, bloggers and many others using Ayn Rand’s novel Atlas Shrugged as a criticism of the new stimulus package and possible tax increases for the upper class and I find this infuriating beyond measure.
I generally agree with Ayn Rand’s philosophy, the virtue of selfishness, but have a few important reservations. I won’t go into those but will go into the significant problems of how people are using how work. I am also doing no research about this but using my own knowledge. I think any small discrepancies will be forgiven in exchange for my opinion being more informed then people on national television claiming to be experts on the topic. The point being don’t borrow opinions from TV pundits because they spew ideology. Anyway.
First of all, it’s extremely important to understand the context of Rand’s work and the full body of her work. Rand formed her philosophy after growing up in the early days of the U.S.S.R. Her high praise of capitalism is certainly due to the abysmal conditions she lived in under communism. In fact her first novel, Anathem, was more a warning against conformity in communism then a statement on economics. In her rejection of communism Rand pursued the extreme and much of her work is criticized for simplifying complex issues in an unrealistic manner. Her novels are powerful and moving but often at the expense of logic.
Second, if you have actually read Atlas Shrugged with any level of intelligence you would see that Rand would detest the people who have plunged the country into economic chaos. In fact, her novel is a call for people, like TV pundits, who produce nothing to get the hell out of the way and allow intelligent people to solve the problems. One can certainly view Ayn Rand’s novel as prescient but not in regard to Obama’s policies but in regard to the short sighted, ignorant greed displayed by Wall Street (etc.) in destroying the economic foundation of the country.
Finally, if you are going to use Rand’s philosophy on economics as a foundation for an argument why not use the god damn book she wrote about her philosophy, The Virtue of Selfishness? But I guess that doesn’t sound as catchy when your beating your viewers over the head with ignorance. And it probably doesn’t help when you don’t understand her philosophy.
This is why I have to make a concentrated effort to not check out of the system (ironically, Atlas Shrugged-style, well, if I actually produced something). I know little about politics, nothing about economics yet people forming the national zeitgeist are painfully ignorant to me.
The silver lining here is that when Rush Limbaugh becomes relevant things can’t get any worse.